Each year, we test the newest wearable devices on the market, so you don't have to. Based on these tests, we make recommendations based on numerous factors.
Withings Move
Value in health tracking
Pros
- Inexpensive
- Great app that collects lots of data
- Long battery life
Cons
- Plastic case
The Withings Move fitness watch tracks key health metrics for much less than $100. The device is available in various color choices.
Withings Steel
Better materials
Pros
- More customization options
- Stainless steel case
Cons
- Older product
- More expensive
- Less battery life
The Withings Steel tracks the same metrics as the Withings Move but costs more money. For this, you get a stainless steel case.
Both the Withings Move and Withings Steel are entry-level fitness bands for their respective product lines. The one that's right for you will probably come down to price and durability.
Look at the differences
If you're looking for a fitness band that tracks your daily movements and sleep, you can't go wrong with either of these choices. Still, for most folks, we recommend the 2019 Withings Move over the Withings Steel for several reasons.
| Withings Move | Withings Steel | |
|---|---|---|
| Color choices | 5+ | Various |
| Case | Plastic | Stainless Steel |
| Bottom Case | Stainless Steel | Stainless Steel |
| Built-in GPS | Yes | No |
| Battery life | 18 months | 8 months |
| Fitness and Health monitoring | Yes | Yes |
| Sleep tracking | Yes | Yes |
| Water resistance | Up to 50m | Up to 50m |
| App | Health Mate, iOS and Android | Health Mate, iOS and Android |
Both of these watches feature traditional analog faces that show the current time and how far you've gone to reach your daily steps goal. The free Health Mate app for iOS and Android is where you'll find other metrics captured by the watches. These readings include distance and calories, running and swimming, and sleep analysis.
The Withings Move is our choice because of its low price and long battery life. On the last point, the Withings Move can last up to 18 months before needing a new battery, versus eight months for the Withings Steel. The Move also includes built-in GPS with Bluetooth Low Energy. This new and improved model can keep track of where you are during exercises without needing your phone.
By contrast, the Withings Steel (once called the Activité Steel) is one of the company's oldest fitness bands. Unlike the newer Withings Move, the Steel could be replaced or discontinued at any time. Since the Steel was first released, there is now a Steel HR and Steel HR Sport, each which has more features than the original.
If you can get past its age, the Withings Steel still provides features worth considering. For one, as its name suggests, the Steel's case is made from Stainless Steel versus the plastic found on the Withings Move. This type of material makes the watch more durable. There's also more color choices currently available for the Withings Steel. Using an online tool, you can customize the watch's face color and kind of band (silicone, leather, or Milanese). This customization isn't yet possible for the Withings Move.
The bottom line: In this comparison, save your money and go with the Withings Move. A next-generation Withings Steel could arrive on the market soon, thereby making the current model obsolete. The Move, despite have a plastic case, has a stainless steel back and soft silicone band. Plus, did we mention the 18 months battery life?
Withings Move
Inexpensive choice
Simple design, easy to use
Track your sleep and daily movements on a budget with the colorful Withings Move. Thanks to the internal GPS, you can leave your phone at home during exercise routines and track your movements.
Withings Steel
Elegant beauty
More durable, but also more expensive
The Withings Steels remains a good choice because of its stainless steel case, but its getting old. We recommend the Withings Move instead.
No comments:
Post a Comment